The Kth Smallest Instructions problem asks for the kth lexicographically smallest instruction sequence to travel in a grid from (0, 0) to a destination. By applying state transition dynamic programming, this problem can be efficiently solved by tracking the number of possible paths at each step and making decisions based on combinations, ensuring the correct instruction sequence is generated.
Problem Statement
Bob is at the top-left corner of a grid and wants to move to a destination at (row, column). He can only move right ('H') or down ('V'). There are multiple ways to reach the destination, and the goal is to determine the kth smallest lexicographical instruction sequence that leads Bob to the destination.
Each instruction sequence consists of exactly row 'H' moves and column 'V' moves. The number of such sequences is given by nCr(row + column, row). The challenge is to compute the kth sequence efficiently using a combination of dynamic programming and combinatorics, while maintaining the correct order of movements.
Examples
Example 1
Input: destination = [2,3], k = 1
Output: "HHHVV"
All the instructions that reach (2, 3) in lexicographic order are as follows: ["HHHVV", "HHVHV", "HHVVH", "HVHHV", "HVHVH", "HVVHH", "VHHHV", "VHHVH", "VHVHH", "VVHHH"].
Example 2
Input: destination = [2,3], k = 2
Output: "HHVHV"
Example details omitted.
Example 3
Input: destination = [2,3], k = 3
Output: "HHVVH"
Example details omitted.
Constraints
- destination.length == 2
- 1 <= row, column <= 15
- 1 <= k <= nCr(row + column, row), where nCr(a, b) denotes a choose b.
Solution Approach
State Transition Dynamic Programming
The problem can be modeled as a state transition where at each step, you decide whether to move right ('H') or down ('V'). By using dynamic programming, we track the number of possible paths from the current state to the destination and make decisions based on lexicographical order. The DP table stores how many ways there are to reach each intermediate point, allowing us to generate the kth sequence without having to enumerate all paths.
Combinatorics for Path Count Calculation
At each step, we need to decide whether moving right or down yields the kth sequence. The number of possible paths from a given point can be determined using combinatorics. Specifically, the number of paths from (x, y) to (row, column) is calculated using the binomial coefficient, nCr(row - x + column - y, row - x). This allows us to efficiently determine which move corresponds to the kth sequence.
Efficient Calculation of the kth Sequence
Instead of generating all possible paths, we can directly compute the kth sequence by progressively deciding whether to move right or down. For each decision point, we use the precomputed DP table and binomial coefficients to choose the appropriate move. This avoids the need to generate and sort all paths, making the solution efficient even for larger grid sizes.
Complexity Analysis
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Time | Depends on the final approach |
| Space | Depends on the final approach |
The time complexity of this approach is dominated by the computation of binomial coefficients and dynamic programming state transitions. Since there are row + column steps, the time complexity is O(row * column), and each decision step involves calculating binomial coefficients in constant time. The space complexity is O(row * column) due to the DP table used to store intermediate results.
What Interviewers Usually Probe
- The candidate demonstrates understanding of dynamic programming and combinatorics.
- The candidate efficiently applies binomial coefficients to reduce the problem complexity.
- The candidate navigates the state transition approach to solve the problem without brute-forcing all paths.
Common Pitfalls or Variants
Common pitfalls
- Forgetting to consider the lexicographical order of instructions, leading to incorrect kth sequences.
- Miscomputing the binomial coefficients, resulting in an inefficient or incorrect path count.
- Not using dynamic programming to optimize the calculation of intermediate results, leading to unnecessary recomputation.
Follow-up variants
- Given a different destination (row, column), how would the approach change?
- How would you modify the approach for finding the largest lexicographical instruction sequence?
- What happens if there are constraints on the number of right or down moves allowed?
How GhostInterview Helps
- GhostInterview helps by providing an optimized approach that uses dynamic programming to solve the problem efficiently, even for larger inputs.
- It assists in reducing the complexity of the problem by applying combinatorics to calculate possible paths without having to generate them all.
- GhostInterview guides you to avoid unnecessary computations and stay focused on state transitions, ensuring an optimal and correct solution.
Topic Pages
Related GhostInterview Pages
- LeetCode Interview Copilot - Use GhostInterview as a live solver when you want direct help with LeetCode-style coding questions.
- Coding Interview Assistant - See how GhostInterview supports array, string, linked list, graph, and tree interview workflows.
- How GhostInterview Works - Review the screenshot, reasoning, and answer flow before using the solver in a live interview.
FAQ
What is the main approach for solving the Kth Smallest Instructions problem?
The main approach involves using state transition dynamic programming to track the number of possible paths, combined with combinatorial calculations to directly compute the kth smallest lexicographic sequence.
How do you calculate the number of possible paths from a point to the destination?
The number of possible paths is calculated using binomial coefficients, specifically nCr(row - x + column - y, row - x), where (x, y) is the current point and (row, column) is the destination.
Why is dynamic programming important in solving this problem?
Dynamic programming helps by storing intermediate results, which avoids recomputing the number of paths multiple times, thus optimizing the solution and making it feasible for larger grids.
What are the constraints for the Kth Smallest Instructions problem?
The constraints are that destination.length == 2, 1 <= row, column <= 15, and 1 <= k <= nCr(row + column, row), where nCr is the binomial coefficient.
What happens if k exceeds the total number of possible paths?
If k exceeds the total number of paths from (0, 0) to (row, column), the problem would not have a valid kth sequence, and the answer should handle such edge cases.
Need direct help with Kth Smallest Instructions instead of spending more time grinding it?
Download GhostInterview when you want a LeetCode solver, not another long practice loop. Capture Kth Smallest Instructions from a screenshot, get the answer path and complexity, and use supported stealth workflows that stay outside captured layers.
Capture the prompt fast instead of rewriting the problem by hand.
Get the solution path, trade-offs, and complexity summary in one pass.
Stay outside captured layers on supported screen-share workflows.
Stay in the same pattern family
Determine the number of ways to reorder an array to get the same binary search tree (BST) from its insertion order.
Open problem page#1735 Count Ways to Make Array With ProductDetermine the number of arrays of size n where the product equals k using prime factorization and combinatorial DP techniques.
Open problem page#1467 Probability of a Two Boxes Having The Same Number of Distinct BallsCompute the probability that two boxes contain the same number of distinct balls using careful combinatorial and DP methods.
Open problem page