The Nim Game involves removing stones optimally to win. By understanding the mathematical strategy, you can decide whether the starting player wins or loses based on the number of stones. When playing optimally, the solution can be derived with a simple modulo operation.
Problem Statement
In the Nim Game, you and a friend take turns removing stones from a heap. On each turn, a player can remove 1, 2, or 3 stones from the heap. The player who removes the last stone wins. Given an integer n representing the number of stones in the heap, return true if the first player can win, assuming both players play optimally. Otherwise, return false.
For example, if there are 4 stones, the first player cannot win regardless of their moves, while with 1 or 2 stones, the first player can always win. The solution revolves around determining if n leads to a winning position for the first player. The key lies in recognizing a pattern based on modulo 4.
Examples
Example 1
Input: n = 4
Output: false
These are the possible outcomes:
- You remove 1 stone. Your friend removes 3 stones, including the last stone. Your friend wins.
- You remove 2 stones. Your friend removes 2 stones, including the last stone. Your friend wins.
- You remove 3 stones. Your friend removes the last stone. Your friend wins. In all outcomes, your friend wins.
Example 2
Input: n = 1
Output: true
Example details omitted.
Example 3
Input: n = 2
Output: true
Example details omitted.
Constraints
- 1 <= n <= 231 - 1
Solution Approach
Mathematical Pattern (Modulo 4)
The solution hinges on recognizing the mathematical pattern based on modulo 4. If n % 4 == 0, then the first player will lose if both play optimally. For any other value of n, the first player has a winning strategy. This pattern forms the core of the solution and allows for an O(1) time complexity.
Game Theory Application
The problem is grounded in game theory, where players alternate moves. By evaluating the possible outcomes, we can conclude that if the number of stones modulo 4 is 0, the first player will eventually be forced into a losing position, given optimal play from both sides.
Optimal Play Analysis
The key to solving this problem lies in understanding that removing stones to a multiple of 4 ensures victory. Players need to think ahead and make moves that leave their opponent with a losing position, thus forcing them to eventually lose the game.
Complexity Analysis
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Time | Depends on the final approach |
| Space | Depends on the final approach |
The time complexity is O(1) as the solution only requires a single modulo operation. The space complexity is O(1) since no additional space is needed apart from the input variable.
What Interviewers Usually Probe
- A correct approach identifies the modulo 4 pattern for optimal play.
- The candidate should recognize the game theory basis for the solution.
- Candidates who try brute force simulations instead of a mathematical solution may need further guidance.
Common Pitfalls or Variants
Common pitfalls
- Overcomplicating the solution by simulating all possible moves instead of using the modulo 4 strategy.
- Failing to recognize that the winning and losing positions are based on multiples of 4.
- Misunderstanding the alternating nature of the game and assuming a winning strategy when n % 4 == 0.
Follow-up variants
- What if players can remove 1, 2, or 3 stones, but the first player can remove up to 4 stones?
- How would the game change if there were more than 3 players, all taking turns to remove stones?
- What happens if the first player can only remove 1 stone per turn?
How GhostInterview Helps
- GhostInterview helps identify the mathematical pattern that leads to an optimal solution, simplifying the problem to a modulo operation.
- GhostInterview suggests focusing on game theory aspects and optimal strategies for quick and correct solutions.
- GhostInterview provides clarity on the common pitfalls, ensuring that you don’t waste time on brute-force solutions or misinterpreting the problem.
Topic Pages
Related GhostInterview Pages
- LeetCode Interview Copilot - Use GhostInterview as a live solver when you want direct help with LeetCode-style coding questions.
- Coding Interview Assistant - See how GhostInterview supports array, string, linked list, graph, and tree interview workflows.
- How GhostInterview Works - Review the screenshot, reasoning, and answer flow before using the solver in a live interview.
FAQ
What is the mathematical pattern in the Nim Game?
The key pattern is based on modulo 4. If the number of stones is divisible by 4, the first player will lose. Otherwise, they can win.
How does game theory apply to the Nim Game?
Game theory helps determine optimal strategies by analyzing possible moves and ensuring that players always end up in a winning position when possible.
What happens if there are 5 stones in the heap?
With 5 stones, the first player can always win by removing 1 stone and leaving 4, which is a losing position for the opponent.
What is the time complexity of the solution?
The time complexity is O(1) since it involves only a single modulo operation.
How can I optimize my solution for the Nim Game?
The most efficient solution is to use the modulo 4 strategy, which guarantees optimal performance in constant time.
Need direct help with Nim Game instead of spending more time grinding it?
Download GhostInterview when you want a LeetCode solver, not another long practice loop. Capture Nim Game from a screenshot, get the answer path and complexity, and use supported stealth workflows that stay outside captured layers.
Capture the prompt fast instead of rewriting the problem by hand.
Get the solution path, trade-offs, and complexity summary in one pass.
Stay outside captured layers on supported screen-share workflows.
Stay in the same pattern family
The Chalkboard XOR Game is a game theory problem involving array manipulation and bitwise XOR, where players alternate erasing elements from a chalkboard.
Open problem page#1025 Divisor GameDivisor Game is a game theory problem where players take turns subtracting divisors of a number n until one player loses.
Open problem page#319 Bulb SwitcherBulb Switcher challenges you to find how many bulbs remain on after n toggling rounds using a math-based insight.
Open problem page